"The Shoemaker's Magician" Book Review

Written by Zach Rosenberg

Published by Agora Books

the shoemakers magician cynthia pelayo poster large

Written by Cynthia Pelayo
2023, 336 pages, Fiction
Released on March 21st, 2023


Hot on the heels of her landmark breakout Children of Chicago, Cynthia Pelayo cements her name as a horror legend with The Shoemaker’s Magician, a paean to film, magic, Chicago and horror. Pelayo leads the reader through the winding streets of Chicago, where the supernatural is very real, where monsters and magicians flourish.

When a brutal murder is committed near a Chicago theater, a homicide detective is called to investigate. His wife Paloma, Polly for short, happens to be an expert on horror films. A survivor of abuse, Polly realizes comfort in the macabre she finds on celluloid and teaches her beloved son Bela about this particular magic. Notably, Polly is writing a dissertation on Grand Vespertillo, the beloved horror host. With the mystery of a fabled lost film at the center of gruesome murders, Polly must conduct her own investigation with dark forces targeting her family.

The Shoemaker’s Magician is not a sequel in the conventional sense. Though there are references to Children of Chicago, Pelayo weaves a whole new story with brand new characters, save for one exception: the city of Chicago itself. A twisted, urban sprawl filled with creatures of myth and legend, but also with wonder and magic.

Chicago is powerful and cruel, offering evil and hope with either hand. Polly is a perfect viewpoint character; a survivor of abuse who engages heavily with the nightmares of celluloid so she might ease her sufferings. She’s a devoted mother who fiercely loves her son, and her knowledge of film bespeaks an absolute love of cinema from Pelayo herself.

Make no mistake, The Shoemaker’s Magician is a novel of love. Amidst the horror, Polly knows she loves Bela and will protect him from whatever forces hunt him. Facts about Chicago, both modern and antique, permeate the book. Pelayo also provides ample education on cinema and theater with their history in Chicago, but also film. This novel could not be written without a deep compassion and appreciation for its subject matter.

With so many streets to travel down, Pelayo chooses the most magic of them all.


Overall: 4.5 Star Rating Cover
Buy from Amazon US.
Buy from Amazon UK.
Buy from BAM.

Hungers as Old as This Land banner

This page includes affiliate links where Horror DNA may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Zach Rosenberg
Staff Reviewer
Zach Rosenberg is a fantasy and horror writer living in Florida. He appreciates the ocean, wildlife and his love of literature was constantly nurtured growing up where he practically lived in the libraries, reading every horror and fantasy book he could get his hands on. His print debut short story "The Teeth Of the Deeps" is featured in the fifth short story collection from Dead Sea Press.
Other articles by this writer



Join Us!

Hit the buttons below to follow us, you won't regret it...